Commerce City passes municipal sentencing and jury-trial changes

Two ordinances cap some municipal-court sentences at state-law maximums and revise when defendants can demand a jury, with exceptions for some infractions and defendants under 18.

Interior view of a courtroom with benches and glass partitions.
Interior view of a courtroom with benches and glass partitions.

Published at

Commerce City Council passed two ordinances on final reading Nov. 16: one caps some municipal-court sentences at state-law maximums, and the other removes the city’s waiver of imprisonment as a reason to deny a jury trial. The adopted Ordinance 2807 makes the jury-trial change.

Under Ordinance 2807, the city’s code will follow Colorado’s jury-trial rule, which turns on whether a comparable state offense carries possible imprisonment, rather than whether the city chooses to seek jail. Defendants must still demand a jury under court procedures, as state law provides.

The ordinance keeps exceptions for cases involving only civil or traffic infractions when no comparable state statute allows imprisonment, and for defendants who were under 18 at the time of the alleged offense. Those cases are tried to the court unless state law otherwise allows a jury.

Ordinance 2806 limits a municipal sentence for an offense with a comparable state misdemeanor or petty-offense counterpart to the maximum penalty allowed under state law. The measure responds to the Colorado Supreme Court’s December 2025 decision in People v. Camp, which held that a municipality cannot impose a harsher penalty than state law allows for identical conduct. The court’s opinion distinguished offenses without an identical state counterpart.

Ordinance 2807 takes effect under Section 5.3 of the city charter but does not state a calendar date. The city’s notice language for ordinances passed on second reading says they take effect five days after publication; the ordinance does not identify its publication date.