Commerce City approves cap on sentences for conduct also barred by state law
The ordinance limits city penalties to state maximums for matching conduct, following a Colorado Supreme Court ruling.
Published at
Commerce City Council approved an ordinance on final reading Nov. 16 that caps sentences under the city’s general penalties code at state maximums when a city offense covers the same conduct as a state misdemeanor or petty offense. The change follows a Colorado Supreme Court ruling limiting municipal sentences in those cases, Ordinance 2806 says.
The ordinance amends Section 1-3003 of the Commerce City Revised Municipal Code. It bars a sentence from exceeding the applicable state maximum for incarceration, fines or other penalties. Its recitals cite the limited exception established in the state Supreme Court’s December 2025 decision in In re People v. Camp and In re People v. Simons.
In that decision, the court held that when a municipal ordinance and a state misdemeanor or petty-offense law prohibit identical conduct, a city cannot impose a higher maximum penalty than state law allows for the corresponding offense. The ruling did not bar the municipal prosecutions before the court; it limited the sentences available for conduct with a state-law counterpart.
The cap depends on which state offense covers the conduct; it does not set one lower maximum for every city offense. The ordinance retains the city code’s penalty categories, including a general misdemeanor term of up to 364 days and listed fines of $1,000 for a first fireworks offense, $2,000 for subsequent fireworks offenses, and $500 for littering or illegal dumping. When a corresponding state offense has a lower maximum, the city sentence cannot exceed that limit.
The ordinance says it takes effect under Section 5.3 of the city charter but does not specify a calendar date.